Losing weight and keeping it off: what happens when the structure goes away

nathan
Author nathan
Date Logged 2026.09.19
Category Client Stories
System Status: Active Reading

A few weeks ago Brad and I walked into the bush with three kids between us, one of his and two of mine, and camped in the middle of nowhere.

Three to four hours of walking to get in, packs on. No car park at the other end. We got in before dark and lit a fire.

What makes that day worth writing about is not that it happened. It is that for Brad it was ordinary.

Brad on the walk in, years after losing weight and keeping it off
The way in. Three to four hours of this, with packs, with kids.

He has been hiking like this for years, ever since the first time we worked together. Six years ago he could not have walked in there. Now it is just what he does, and that is a better result than any number on a scale.

What a day like that actually asks of you

People underestimate a day like that, because it is not a run.

  • You are carrying a pack, and it does not come off for four hours.
  • You are carrying gear for a kid as well as yourself.

Which is worth saying plainly. Getting fit enough to hike was never the goal. It arrived because he finally had a body that could handle it, and then it stayed.

The message, in 2019

Brad sent me a Facebook message on 13 May 2019. A mate had given him my details, and he would be keen to have a chat and see if I could help him in any way.

Asking for help is the hardest part. Most people who need a coach never send that message. Brad did, and over the next couple of years he lost 25kg and got fit.

What the training looked like back then

I still have the original spreadsheet, and the first block from December 2020 looks nothing like what he does now.

There were no barbells in it, and sessions were not tied to days of the week, because the win then was getting them done at all.

The weeks either side were similar. Walks at MAF, ROMWOD, three hip flexor mobility days, and a line in the plan literally called Low Hanging Fruit.

By May 2021 that had built into one minute of running at 160 cadence against two minutes of walking, and eventually a 13km easy run. From walking, in five months.

What he lost was not the fitness. It was the progression

Here is the part most client stories leave out. By the end of that first stretch, Brad had what he came for.

“He took the time to listen attentively to my concerns and aspirations, tailoring a personalised program that perfectly aligned with my fitness level, lifestyle, and preferences.”

“One day I’m sure I’ll be equipped with the tools and knowledge to continue my fitness journey independently, empowered to maintain a healthier lifestyle long after Nathan gives me the boot again!”

Brad Giblin, May 2023  ·  Read the full testimonial

He wrote that in May 2023, near the top of that first stretch. He was right about the last part, although not in the way either of us expected.

What went away was the structure. No programming, no accountability, nobody asking how the week went. He did not fall apart and he did not lose all of it. But he stopped moving forward, and slowly some of it slid.

That is the honest cost of no structure. It is rarely a collapse. It is a plateau that lasts long enough to start going the other way.

In May 2025 he came back, and he came back for the structure.

What a week actually looked like in 2025

Three sessions locked in. Anything else optional.

Week commencing 19 May 2025
The first block. Three sessions locked in, three optional on top.
Monday
Upper body
3 rounds as a warm up, easy, then 5 working rounds
12 x Dumbbell Bench Press @ 70% PE
7 x Deep Push Ups
Farmers Carry @ 20kg per arm, 20m up and back
90sec rest
Then 5 sets: 12 x Lat Pulldown @ 70% PE
Then 5 sets: 12 x Seated Rows @ 70% PE
Finish, 6 sets: 20cal row or ski erg @ 70 to 80% PE, 60sec complete rest
Tuesday
Posterior + conditioning
1.5km power walk at 5km/hr to open up
1 warm up round, then 5 working rounds
10 x Barbell Deadlift @ 60% PE
1 x 20m Sled or Tank Push
Long rest, 3min
Then 3 rounds: 1 x heavy slow Sled Push, 8 x Decline Sit Ups
Then 6 sets: 8 x slow controlled Crunches
Finish, 6 rounds: 40sec Ski Erg @ 80% PE, 40sec complete rest
The sheet says it out loud: you do not need to kill yourself here just because it is the end.
Thursday
1:1 with me
Assessment and movement work, 4:30pm
Optional
If he had more in him
Upper body accessory work: incline bench, seated shoulder press, flat bench, bicep curls, push ups
Or 6km easy power walk
Or 50 to 60min at LAHR, his MAF number minus 10 beats, on the cross trainer or bike

Notice what is not in there. No prescribed weights, no pace targets. Everything is a percentage of perceived effort, because I want him reading his body rather than his watch.

Brad pushing a loaded sled across the gym floor
Sled pushes. Heavy and slow, exactly as written in the program.

What changed in 2026

Once the aerobic base was back, the work moved toward shaping.

Week commencing 12 January 2026
The shape changes. Shaping work, incline walking, and a loaded pack.
Monday
1:1 PT
Session with me at his gym
Tuesday
Easy + push ups
5km walk at an enjoyable pace
Every 1km, stop and do 20 Push Ups
Wednesday
Upper body
4 easy sets as a warm up, then 5 working sets
10 x Incline Bench Press @ 80% PE, 1 to 2min rest
4 rounds: 12 x Cable Chest Flys, 3 x Bicep Chin Ups, long rest
4 rounds: 12 x Cable Seated Row @ 90% PE, 40sec Plank Hold on hands or to failure
4 rounds: 15 x Decline Sit Ups, 45 to 60sec rest
Chin ups told him plainly not to rush them.
Thursday
Incline work
5kg weighted pack, a backpack with 5L of water in it
15min incline walk @ 5km/hr @ 5% incline
10 x 40sec surges @ 6.5km/hr, 20sec off the belt between each
2 moderate rounds @ 8% incline: 3min at max walking speed, the pace just before you would have to run, 2min complete rest
4 very hard rounds @ 12% incline: same again
Friday
Rest
Rest
Weekend
His call
As desired
Week commencing 26 January 2026
A real week, including what Brad wrote back to me.
Monday
Play
Play as desired
5km walk with a 15kg pack
Tuesday
Legs + pull
5 to 7 rounds: 10 per leg TRX Pistol Squats, Weighted Walking Lunges with a barbell @ 80 to 90% PE, 2 to 3min rest
4 to 5 sets: 12 x TRX Hamstring Curls, short rest
4 to 6 rounds: 10 x Pendlay Rows @ 80% PE, 10 x Dumbbell Bench Press, elbows tucked, @ 80% PE, 2 to 3min rest
3 to 4 sets: 12 x Decline Sit Ups
Wednesday
Walk
6.5km at an enjoyable pace, no running
Brad wrote back in the sheet: 6.5km treadmill, 5.5 pace with 5.5 incline, plus a 15kg pack. He went harder than I asked.
Thursday
PT
90min full body session
Saturday
To be confirmed
Left open
My note to him that week: can we do more weights here? His answer: out for the day, can do an early morning session in the home gym.

The food, and the part nobody warns you about

Back then the lever was restriction. Protein sat between 100g and 150g a day, carbohydrate was capped and at times under 75g, and the number we worked to kept getting smaller. His logged intake ran at a median under 1,500 calories a day.

The shift is easier to see than to describe. These are medians from his own logging, not the targets we set.

Median macros logged per dayGrams per day, taken from Brad’s own daily logging in both spreadsheets2020 to 20212025 to 20260g60g120g180g115g156gProtein58g106gCarbohydratenot tracked78gFatMedian calories eaten per day1,470to1,850Carbohydrate was capped back then, at times under 75g a day. There is no cap now.

It worked, until it did not. Once the number was low enough the scale stopped moving anyway.

Here is what that taught me, and it is the thing almost nobody writes about. Losing weight takes effort. Keeping it takes more, because you cannot eat less forever.

Bring them back too fast and the body fat comes with them, because the body has not had time to adapt. So you do it slowly, over months, while the scale does nothing. It is monotonous, and it is the most important part of the whole thing.

Which is why I will not push a deficit so low that someone has no willpower left to climb out of it. The way out costs more than the way in.

Brad and I stopped working together around that point. He had got where he wanted to be and he was content. My view was that his base needed to come up. A coach can advise, the client decides. It is why the old spreadsheet has no record of his intake climbing back up.

The numbers, since you will ask

Across 2026 he has gone from around 114kg to sitting consistently at 103 to 104.

Then he had seven weeks off. No structured training, no tracking, no plan. He came back and had not gained a kilo.

If you have ever lost weight and watched it creep back on, you will know why that is the part I am most proud of.

Losing weight and keeping it off are two different jobs

What do you do when you are happy where you are?

Nothing dramatic happens. There is no progress photo. You keep turning up, and the reward for doing it well is that nothing changes.

Carrying one of the little ones on the trail
The last stretch, with a passenger. This is what the training is for.

What all of the training is really for

One of Brad’s inner goals, the one underneath everything else, is to live life to the fullest and have a body that can lead him in that direction.

Read that again. The body is not the goal. The body is what makes the goal possible.

Every sled push and every incline round is a deposit toward days like that one, and those days are not rare for him any more.

The campfire at the overnight camp with the kids
The fire, and three kids a long way from a screen.

There is no training metric for a night around a fire with your kids. But it is the entire point.

What is next for Brad

Not an event. He has no interest in racing and he does not need one.

His next job is consistency, and the slow work of bringing his calories back up to something sustainable without overhauling his life to do it. That means eating a little more, week after week, while the scale stays where it is, and holding your nerve when there is nothing to show for it.

The muscle tone he wants comes out of that. It does not come out of another deficit.

If any of this sounds like you

Whether you are where Brad was in 2019, or where he was in the quiet years without structure, both are coaching problems and both are solvable. Losing weight and keeping it off is rarely one job done once.

Brad sent two lines on a Tuesday in May. Seven years later, a night in the bush with his kid is just a weekend.

That is what coaching with MFHP Adventures is for.